5 Uses of Lyric Replacement Songwriting

Multiple books have been written about the vast array of ways music therapists use songwriting clinically, and in this early stage of my career I enjoy knowing I’ve only begun to scratch the surface of songwriting’s potential. Thankfully, the breadth of possibilities means there are opportunities everywhere, for any of us to experiment with (and by “any of us,” I mean you and the people you dare to try it too!)

One of the easiest ways to start is by simply replacing the words of a tune you know well. Even one or two phrases can be a powerful tool to aid you or someone else in exploring distant memories or complex emotions, remembering comforting advice, or making you laugh. To get your mind rolling, here are five examples of how I’ve used lyric-replacement songwriting in my sessions. 

1. Developing a story: Hearing your past, present, or imagined experiences in a song creates a mysterious form of authenticity that can be very validating. (Side note: I think this feeling of authenticity is related to why it can be uncomfortable to be sung to on your birthday.) As people think through what they’d like to say, already knowing the melody and rhythmic structure you’re shooting for can help channel your focus and reduce decision fatigue. Especially for clients who struggle with short-term memory, songwriting can allow them to connect longer trains of thought as they read, hear, or sing the lyrics written minutes or days previously, just needing to add one more thought at a time. 

With clients whose objectives include emotional awareness or emotional expression, I often find that the structure of a familiar song’s verse aids in the process of deciding what to write. If the client enjoys “This Land Is Your Land,” and I suggest our lyrics start with “When friends annoy me…” the client’s musical aesthetics immediately provide some internal motivation to complete the phrase, and lend a satisfying sense of completion when they do. 

This is also why I use songwriting to help clients who struggle with some (or all) 2. Open-Ended Questions: when a question is posed to you as part of a melody you know well, parts of you that may have felt frozen or conflicted about what, whether, or how to answer are suddenly aligned toward completing the phrase and achieving that aesthetic payoff. 

Aesthetic payoffs can be leveraged from practical uses in 3. Call-and-Response Reminders. Pick a song with a natural punctuation that sets up the ‘response,’ like the implied colon in “This little light of mine: I’m gonna let it shine.” Using that example, if a client has a tendency to slip on snowy driveways, I could teach their parents to sing “When the ground is icy…” and the client to respond “I take smaller steps.” 


Putting our strong memories for music to work in specific situations also makes songwriting a helpful tool for 4. Creating a Coping Mechanism. For a client who experiences distressing intrusive thoughts, he quickly learned to sing himself the chorus of “Let It Go,” with personalized lyrics following that title phrase that provide the combination of humor and self-affirmations he needs to regain perspective and a sense of control. 

The familiar dimension of lyric-replacement songwriting is an important key to its success when the goal is 5. Learning Something Difficult. (Think how hard it would be to teach toddlers the alphabet without a lyric-replacement version of “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star!”) In my personal life I still use this hack to memorize my credit card number – groups of four digits play in my head to the tune of “YMCA.” I’ll leave you with a bit of songwriting that I found very fun to create, and I hope you enjoy trying some lyric-replacing yourself! Can you guess which of the melodies mentioned above fits these lyrics?

Letter O, Letter O, sometimes sounds like "bro, go home!"

Letter O, Letter O, sometimes rocks out like a Rolling Stone

But sometimes O...sounds like "hot dog" so...

Don't get hot and bothered, there's lots of ways to say O.

Next
Next

A Fun, Original, Gratitude Song!